Is It Better To Have A Vacuum With Or Without A Bag
Although bagged and bagless vacuums work toward the same goal, removing dirt and debris from your home, their method of waste disposal differs. Each type has its benefits and drawbacks but as you may have guessed from the title of this post, there is a clear winner.
Let us discuss why bagged vacuums are better!
Bagged Vs Bagless Vacuum Cleaners
Purchasing a new vacuum cleaner probably seems like a simple task, but once you start to explore explore all of the options, features, brands and accessories, the process can quickly become overwhelming. At first glance, vacuum cleaners come in so many models from dozens of brands all with their own set of features and accessories. The prices range can from under $100 to over $2,000. With so many choices and factors to consider it can be hard to decide which unit is right for you.
Without taking all of these variable into consideration, you will undoubtedly buy a unit that wont be the best for you and your living situation. But, it doesnt have to be a difficult process. In fact, its pretty easy once you figure out what you want, and how much youre willing to spend. But, first lets take a step back and ask yourself this one simple question.
The 6 Best Vacuums For Allergies Of 2022
The Shark Navigator uses a sealed air system to trap allergens and dust
Christina Oehler is a commerce editor for Verywell Health. She has a degree from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and has work published on sites like Health, Shape, and Brides.
We independently research, test, review, and recommend the bestproducts. Healthcare professionals review articles for medical accuracy. Learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.
Verywell Health / Phoebe Cheong
Having indoor allergies can leave you with red, itchy eyes or a cough. You wipe down surfaces but still come home and are triggered by dust or pet hair. The missing ingredient to help assuage indoor allergies could be the type of vacuum you are using. Because dust and animal allergies happen so often, the importance of having a powerful vacuum to suck up any debris that could cause an attack is important.
Read Also: Can Allergies Cause Tonsil Stones
Why Trust The Spruce
This article was written by Sara Coughlin, a freelance writer and The Spruces small appliances expert. From canister models to dustbusters, shes researched what it takes for a vacuum to stand out in a vast and broad marketand what to look for in up-and-coming models. Additional reporting was done by Ashley Abramson, a writer who has worked as editor for local print and online publications. Her work has also appeared in the New York Times, Washington Post, Allure, InStyle, MyDomaine, and more.
Invest In A Bagged Vacuum
Oreck makes vacuum bags that are lined with antibacterial paper.
While bagless vacuums are way more convenient, bag vacuums can offer better filtration. Take the Oreck Elevate Conquer for example. This vacuum has a bag made of antibacterial paper, and this model also has charcoal-lined filters to prevent dirt leakage. While not all bagged vacuums are this good at filtration, the average bagged vacuum offers better filtration than the average bagless vacuum.
Recommended Reading: What Allergy Medicine Is Stronger Than Zyrtec
Why Is A Bagless Vacuum Better
A bagless vacuum is generally considered to be better than a bagged vacuum for a variety of reasons. Firstly, bagless vacuums eliminate the cost of replacing vacuum bags, which can save you money in the long run.
Secondly, a bagless vacuum is much easier to empty and for some models, there is a clear dust container, so you can see how much dirt has been collected. This makes it easy to know when the vacuum needs to be emptied.
Finally, a bagless vacuum can be more hygienic than a bagged vacuum. This is because the dust and dirt is collected into a sealed container which can be easily sealed and emptied, instead of being trapped in a vacuum bag which can take time to replace.
In summary, a bagless vacuum is a great solution for those looking to save money, have a quick and easy emptying process and maintain a hygienic environment.
What Is A Sealed System
Top-of-the-line vacuum cleaners like the Miele UniQ, SEBO D4 AirBelt or Dyson All Floors not only have certified HEPA filters, but they also feature sealed system engineering, which means that none of the dust will leak from the machine as air passes through it. Some less expensive brands like Electrolux also feature sealed systems and HEPA filters but lack many of the premium features of a luxury brand.
With their sealed system engineering, 9-ply AirClean Filterbags, AirClean HEPA filter, and complete 12 Stage Filtration, Miele vacuum cleaners can eliminate up to 99.99% of household allergens. While some brands can offer similar, none can offer comparable filtration that has been independently certified like Mieles.
Read Also: Is Taking 2 Allergy Pills Bad
What Is A Hepa Filter And How Does It Help With Allergies
HEPA stands for high-efficiency particulate air. A HEPA filter can remove at least 99.97% of airborne particles like dust, pollen, mold, and bacteria with a size of 0.3 microns , according to the Environmental Protection Agency. Theyre commonly used in air filters, which remove airborne allergens, but they can also be used in vacuum cleaners.
When you vacuum, especially on carpeted surfaces, you temporarily stir up the allergens in the air. For those with allergies, this can be disastrous. Allergists recommend masking up while vacuuming to combat symptoms, but the allergens loosened from carpet and upholstery can remain in the air for a couple of hours before settling. Thats where a HEPA filter can help.
HEPA filters help with certain allergens, such as mold and animal dander, but dont always capture all pollen and dust mites, explains Purvi Parikh, MD, an adult and pediatric allergist and immunologist at allergy and asthma associates of Murray Hill in New York City. A vacuum with a HEPA filter helps remove allergens from the environment to alleviate allergy symptoms like itchy eyes, skin, throat, nasal congestion, and asthma.
For allergy sufferers, the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology recommends vacuuming once per week with a HEPA filter. You can wear a mask and gloves and empty the vacuum bag outside to reduce your exposure to allergens.
The Benefits Of Bagged Vacuum Cleaners
Bagged vacuum cleaners have been around for a long time. Typically, the bag fits into a cloth section that zips around the bag, which can be easily removed and replaced whenever it becomes full. While it will vary from model to model, the following list breaks-down the most common benefits that come along with a bagged vacuums.
Read Also: What Is Allergy Medicine Made Of
Loss Of Performance Once Bag Is Full
Bagged vacuum cleaners perform best with empty bag. When bag starts filling with collected dust, its performance gets affected. You might not be able to get optimum performance with a almost full bag. Moreover, its difficult to tell either bag is full with dust or not for old models. Newer models come with a light indication giving a signal that bag needs replacement.
Best Vacuum for Wool Carpet in 2021
Increased Exposure To Allergens:
Oftentimes, especially when attempting to empty the chamber full of dirt and debris, bagless vacuum cleaners may expose users to more dust and allergens than a bagged model. This is mainly due to the fact that the dirt and debris doesnt go into an air-tight bag, but instead, an air-tight chamber. Because the disposal process isnt simply removing a bag, it is possible for some of the dust and allergens to be kicked back into the air while emptying your bagless vacuum.
Don’t Miss: What Is Alpha Gal Allergy
Bag Vs Bagless Vacuum For Allergies
In general, bag vacuums are slightly better for allergy sufferers. This is because bag vacuums let less debris in the air when youre emptying the vacuum. However, new bagless technology has made newer models almost as allergy-friendly to empty as bagged versions.
In both bagged and bagless vacuums, you need to make sure you have good suction and an effective HEPA filter. I say effective, because some vacuums are marketed with a HEPA filter, but its extremely ineffective. I have a full article breaking down the best vacuum for allergies that will guide you on what to look for and my favorite allergy vacuums.
Alternatively, water filtration vacuums are also quite allergy-friendly since they use water to trap dust particles within the machine rather than dispersing them into the air.
Cons Of Bagless Vacuums
The main disadvantage of a bagless vacuum is that they tend to lose suction power over time as the filter gets clogged up with dirt and debris.
This means that you will need to clean or replace the filter on a regular basis if you want your vacuum cleaner to maintain its maximum suction power.
Additionally, some models can be quite noisy due to their strong suction power and lack of sound insulation around the motor.
You May Like: How Long Does It Take For Allergy Test Results
Bissell Cleanview Deluxe Vacuum For Allergies Best On A Budget
Award:Best on a Budget
WHY WE LIKE IT: Budget-conscious vac with a serious feature set for cleanup that includes a light form factor that offers one-handed operation and a bagless design that makes it simple to empty and remove debris.
The Bissell Cleanview Deluxe comes in at a budget-friendly price while offering some features in line with more expensive competitors, such as a light form factor that makes it easy to operate with just one hand. We also loved that it ships with a lengthy and flexible hose, for reaching out-of-the-way places, and that it offers a bagless design that makes it easy to empty debris between cleaning sessions.
Though this vacuum cleaner is extremely light, at less than five pounds, it does not offer a cordless design, despite the power cable being on the lengthy side. Also, this vacuum does offer multi-level filtration, but there is no HEPA filter included. To make emptying the debris and dirt collected much neater and easier, you should try one of the best bagged vacuums.
Bagged Vacuum Vs Bagless
In the comparison between a bagged vacuum vs bagless, there are a few things you should consider . First, lets go over what the model is. After that, well figure out which model is best suited for you.
Insider Tip
Essentially, a bagged vacuum has a bag that collects the debris while you vacuum.
Related:
Read Also: Can Seasonal Allergies Cause Anxiety
Bagless Vacuums Are Bad For Your Health
An independent laboratory confirmed that on average, the leading bagless HEPA-filtered vacuum emitted over 175,900 lung-damaging particles per minute during the test.
What youre breathing in has been linked to bad health effects such as including chronic bronchitis and premature death, according to the Environmental Protection Agency.
Bagless Vacuums are Not Hygienic and Diminish Filtration, Suction and Cleaning Performance Without bags to hold nearly all the captured dirt, the microfilters on bagless vacuums quickly clog from excessive dirt build-up and must be replaced often or a loss of suction and cleaning effectiveness will occur.
And bagless vacuum microfilters are expensive, usually costing more than a multi-year supply of large capacity filter bags. And perhaps the most annoying problem is that dust and other allergens become airborne when emptying bagless vacuum dirt containers.
Why are Bagless Vacuums So Popular? Bagless vacuums outsell bagged vacuums in todays USA marketplace. This should not happen, if one considers the substantial advantages bagged vacuums offer, as compared to bagless machines. But there is a reasonable explanation for this situation.
Simply put, bagless vacuums are popular for two reasons:
Ron Vohs
Are Bagged Vacuums Better For Allergies
Both bagged and bagless vacuum cleaners can help with allergies as long as they have a HEPA filter. But, the allergists we spoke to are partial to bagged vacuums. You dont have to change the HEPA filter as frequently with bagged vacuums compared to bagless, which can reduce your exposure to allergens and potential allergy triggers, Dr. Wright says.
Read Also: Can Allergies Cause Acute Bronchitis
Are Bagless Vacuums Worse
Bagless Vacuums are Not Hygienic and Diminish Filtration, Suction and Cleaning Performance Without bags to hold nearly all the captured dirt, the microfilters on bagless vacuums quickly clog from excessive dirt build-up and must be replaced often or a loss of suction and cleaning effectiveness will occur.
Which type of vacuum cleaner is best for home?
Best Vacuum Cleaners for Home In India
- 1) Karcher WD 3 Multi-Purpose Vacuum Cleaner.
- 2) AGARO Storm 2000 Watts Vacuum Cleaner.
- 3) AGARO Ace 1600-Watts Wet & Dry Stainless Steel Vacuum Cleaner.
- 4) Eureka Forbes Trendy Zip 1000-Watt Vacuum Cleaner.
- 5) Philips PowerPro FC9352/01 Compact Bagless Vacuum Cleaner.
Which bagless vacuum cleaner is best?
Our top pick for a bagless vacuum is the excellent Shark NZ801UKT. Its a powerful vacuum with excellent cleaning performance, hygienic emptying system and a turbo tool for pet hair. If you want a cordless, its hard to beat the Dyson V11 Absolute.
Are HEPA filter vacuums worth it?
Any good vacuum cleaner should stop cat hair and dander. But although a HEPA filter is not a magic bullet by itself, careful vacuuming with a HEPA filter will help catch some of the smaller environmental contaminants we live with. For a cleaner home, theyre worth the added expense.
The Cons Of Bagless Vacuums
On the other hand, there are some drawbacks associated with using a bagless vacuum cleaner. One potential issue is that they tend to spread dust around more than bagged models do this means that if you have allergies or asthma, using a bagged model might be better for your health.
Additionally, some people find them more difficult to empty due to their design depending on your needs, this could be an issue or not.
Finally, some users report experiencing decreased suction power after prolonged use due to clogged filters this is another trade-off between convenience and effectiveness that users must consider when making their decision.
You May Like: Can Allergies Make Your Voice Hoarse
Best Vacuums For Allergy Sufferers
Top picks from Kenmore and Miele that ace CR’s emissions tests
When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission.Learn more.
A good vacuum can be a game-changer for anyone who suffers from seasonal allergies. But if your vacuum spews more dust and debris than it picks up, you could be doing yourself more harm than good.
Thats one reason Consumer Reports measures emissions when we test vacuum cleaners. The best vacuums keep dirt well-contained and the air clear. If youre especially sensitive to dust and allergens, buying a vacuum with a HEPA filter is a good starting point.
Belowin alphabetical order, not in order of CR rankare the bagged upright and canister vacuums from our tests with the lowest emissions. For more choices, see our full vacuum ratings and recommendations.
CR’s take: Strong airflow for tools and superb pet-hair pickup are top attractions of the bagged Kenmore Elite Pet Friendly 31150. Though you can get a fine performer for less, its price includes helpful features, such as a brush on/off switch, which safeguards a bare floor’s finish and prevents scattering of debris suction control, which protects drapes and manual carpet pile-height adjustment. It earns an Excellent rating for clean emissions.
The Most Important Features To Consider
Filtration
If you are looking for a vacuum to lessen allergens in your home, you are going to want to make sure the filtration systems are on point. Look for vacuum cleaners with multi-level filtration systems and tight-fitting sealed systems, with exhaust filters and air filters, that work to disallow particles from escaping the vacuum during cleaning. You will also want to make sure the vacuum includes a genuine HEPA air filter, as these are considered to be the gold standard in filtration to those who suffer from allergies and can thoroughly clean microfibers and all surface types.
Power
As with vacuum cleaners of all types, power is a significant concern. Look for vacuums with advanced motor systems that excel across both carpeting and hard surface types, such as linoleum, tiling, and wood. Make sure the motor is powerful enough to pick up minuscule particles, such as allergens, in addition to making short work out of dirt and debris. Some vacuums also include motors that can handle both wet and dry messes, which is a factor that should be considered.
Attachments and Accessories
Also Check: Can Seasonal Allergies Cause Fever
Require Less Maintenance :
Vacuum cleaners with bags generally require less maintenance than their bagless counterparts. There are many reasons for this, but it mainly boils down to the following Bags can hold up to two pounds of debris so they dont need changed nearly as often. Also, because the filter is built directly into the bag it never needs to be cleaned, and you always know exactly when is the best time to replace the filter.
Is A Bagless Vacuum Better For Allergy Sufferers
Even the tidiest of allergy suffers are susceptible to coming down with symptoms from things hiding out in the carpet. Carpet harbors a number of allergy-aggravating substances especially the dust mite. This is not to say that if you suffer from allergies you should go about ripping up all the carpet in your home. The best way to keep allergens at bay is to care for you carpet properly with regular vacuuming and routine professional carpet cleanings. Vacuuming is the best thing we can do on our own to keep our carpets as clean as possible.
Of course, you will want to make sure you have a high quality and reliable vacuum if you are an allergy sufferer, especially during the spring when so many different allergens can get tracked into the home from outside.
Also Check: Do Allergies Give You A Cough
