Is Alcoholism An Allergy To Alcohol How Should It Be Treated
Is alcoholism an allergy to alcohol? Is it an allergic reaction to alcohol that creates strong cravings for more alcohol? Does this allergy cause a loss of control over drinking?
II. What IS an Allergy?
III. Theory and Evidence
The theory that alcoholism is an allergy is a major part of the Alcoholics Anonymous belief system. And that of other 12 step programs as well. But is alcoholism an allergy?
Histamine And Other Substances May Also Cause Problems
Histamine can trigger sneezing, runny nose and sometimes wheeze, stomach upset and headache. Although the actual amounts vary between different wines, in general there is more histamine in red than white wines and more in Shiraz than Cabernet. Some challenge studies suggest that antihistamines may reduce the severity of problems after wine, but as the challenges were equivalent to only one glass, these medicines probably won’t prevent a hangover! Others substances in wine may also cause problems to some individuals, but these are not well defined.
Can I Be Allergic To Vodka
A true allergic to vodka, or alcohol, is extremely rare so its more likely that you have an intolerance to alcohol in general.
If you experience immedient negative symptoms after drinking vodka, its important to speak to your doctor before drinking again. Just because you may not have an allergy to alcohol doesnt mean that your negative reaction to alcohol is meaningless.
If you find that your reaction is more extreme depending on the type of alcohol you drink, its likely that theres an ingredient in that specific drink thats upsetting your body. Some people find that vodka gives them less of a reaction compared to red wine.
However, it may be that drinks with higher alcohol content impact you worse than those with less alcohol content. If your body has trouble breaking down alcohol it may struggle to deal with alcoholic drinks with a high alcohol content.
Also Check: What Allergy Medicine Is Stronger Than Zyrtec
Alcohol Intolerance Prevention And Skin Treatment Options
Some medicines, such as antihistamine creams or oral medication, may be able to help control flushing of the face or rashes caused by alcohol intolerance or allergies. However, some of these medications will mask the symptoms of a drinking problem and not address the root cause of the reaction.
Alcohol intolerance that is genetically inherited cannot be cured. However, there are ways to curb the harmful effects of both allergy and intolerance.
To do this, a person can:
- Restrict or stop alcohol use completely.
- Quit smoking or avoid exposure to second-hand smoke.
- Stop drinking alcohol when taking certain medications.
- Seek medical attention to identify if your symptoms are intolerance or allergy.
- Do not just rely on antihistamines to alleviate the symptoms.
Theres Much More Evidence
To those of you who have thought or commented that this is only one experiment, I offer you a review of 9 similar priming dose experiments. Again and again, it has been shown that alcohol does not trigger an automatic response of uncontrolled drinking. See this page for more info and full citations: Do Alcoholics Lose Control? The Results of Priming Dose Experiments Say NO
Read Also: Is Palm Oil Safe For Peanut Allergy
Alcohol Intolerance Vs Allergy
Alcohol allergies and alcohol intolerances are not the same thing, though many people confuse the terms. An allergy is more serious than an intolerance, in most cases, but neither of them have pleasant symptoms.
When someone has an alcohol allergy, theyre usually allergic to one of the ingredients used in the beverage. That could be wheat, grades, hops, juniper, or even potatoes.
Their body sees this substance, whatever it is, as an immune threat and treats it like any other virus or bacteria. It tries to get rid of it in any way possible.
Allergic reactions differ between people, but its possible for the throat to swell, killing the person by not allowing them to breathe.
Having an alcohol allergy is rare much rarer than being allergic to dairy or peanuts. If you have issues digesting alcohol, you more likely have alcohol intolerance.
Management Of Alcohol Allergy
Accidental exposure to alcohol may lead to unexpected reactions. Severe alcohol allergy should be managed in the same way as other severe allergic reactions : identify and avoid the cause, wear a medical identification bracelet, and carry adrenaline as part of an emergency action plan if individuals are at risk of potentially life threatening allergic reactions in the future. Information on anaphylaxis is available on the ASCIA website: www.allergy.org.au/patients/about-allergy/anaphylaxis
Also Check: Can Allergy Medicine Raise Blood Pressure
Flushing Is Not An Allergic Reaction
Some people develop severe facial flushing if they drink small amounts of alcohol. This is not an allergic reaction and is most common in those with an Asian background. Other side effects may also occur, including fluttering of the heart , feeling hot, headache, tummy discomfort or a drop in blood pressure These may be related to high blood acetaldehyde levels. Not all flushing is due to alcohol. Flushing can occur in skin conditions like rosacea, menopause, low blood sugar levels , or as a response to some antibiotics or medicines used to treat diabetes or high blood fat levels.
What Happens When Alcoholics Take Alcohol: The Role Of Acetate In Alcohol Cravings
Alcoholics make up about 12% of the population. The body of the alcoholic is physically different. The liver and pancreas of the alcoholic process alcohol at one-third to one-tenth the rate of a normal pancreas and liver.
Now as alcohol enters the body, it breaks down into various components, one of which is acetate. We know now that acetate triggers a craving for more acetate. In a normal drinker, the acetate moves through the system quickly and exits. But that doesnt happen in an alcoholic. In alcoholics, the acetate of the first drink is barely processed out, so by staying in their body, it triggers a craving for more acetate. The alcoholic then has a second drink, now adding to most of the acetate of the first drink, and that makes them want a drink twice as much as the normal drinker. So they have another. Then, having almost three times the craving as a normal drinker, they have another.
You can see from that point how alcoholics have no control over how much they drink. The craving cycle has begun and they have no choice but to keep drinking. Once the acetate accumulates in their body, and that begins to happen with only one drink, they will crave another. And how many times does an alcoholic think it would be nice to have just one drink to relax, but has many more? Now you see why. And this can never change.
Don’t Miss: Dimenhydrinate For Allergies
Alcohol Allergy Vs Intolerance
Most people who have a reaction to alcohol arenât allergic to it. They have an intolerance. They donât have one of the active enzymes needed to process alcohol — alcohol dehydrogenase or aldehyde dehydrogenase . This is often called alcohol intolerance.
- Test your blood
Your doctor also may recommend that you stop drinking all alcoholic beverages for a while. Then you can start again, perhaps trying just one of your go-to drinks at a time. If the reactions return with specific drinks, then you know which ones cause problems for you.
Corn Allergies And Intolerances
To date, the question of whether distilled alcohol made from corn is safe for people with corn allergies has received very little attention in the peer-reviewed medical literature.
A 1999 case study on a patient who had demonstrated corn allergies and anaphylaxis triggered by beer appeared to show that corn-derived distilled alcohol was safe for people with corn allergies.
This case study was cited by the European Food Safety Authority in their position paper stating that distilled alcohol derived from corn was probably safe for patients with corn allergies, especially since scientists could not demonstrate the presence of proteins after the distillation process.
However, given that the clinical evidence on corn and distilled alcohol is so scant, you may wish to talk to your allergist before adding corn-derived distilled alcohol to your diet.
People with corn allergies should avoid alcohol derived from corn, most especially bourbon. Other types of liquor, including gin, whiskey, and some vodkas, may also be distilled from corn, so be sure to always check the label.
While some beers are safethey use non-corn cereal grains, water, yeast, and hopsmany are not. Currently, U.S. manufacturers are not required to list ingredients on malt beverages . Wine is safe for corn allergies and intolerances, but Spanish chicha is another fermented corn-based beverage that should be avoided.
Read Also: Non Drowsy Robitussin
Why Cant I Drink Alcohol Like I Used To
It is common to develop alcohol sensitivity with age. Older adults tend to become intoxicated easier than younger adults. This is because alcohol tolerance decreases as you drink less, which usually happens with age. There are also some natural changes in the body that contribute to this, including:
Higher body fat percentage: everyone, including those who work out regularly and eat healthy, lose muscle and gain fat easier as they get older. This change in body composition causes a higher blood alcohol level in older adults.
Changes in liver health: the liver is an incredible organ, but age takes a toll on it, whether or not you have been watching alcohol consumption and drinking sufficient water. The liver is unable to break down alcohol at a comparable rate to when you were younger. This allows alcohol to stay in your system longer and generally leads to a more heightened feeling of intoxication.
Lower blood volume: as we age, the body loses water and blood volume. This leads to a higher blood alcohol content than if you were to drink the same amount at a younger age. There is a higher percentage of alcohol in the blood and a more heightened feeling of intoxication.
V Is Alcoholism An Allergy To Alcohol
No. The theory that alcoholism is an allergy to alcoholism is clearly false. Its illogical, It lacks any scientific evidence. Even worse, its inconsistent with the nature of allergies.
The allergy theory of alcoholism is only one of A.A.s mistaken beliefs. Another, powerlessness, may contribute to the general ineffectiveness of A.A. and other 12 step programs. They tend to be counterproductive. Theyre less effective than doing nothing.
Also Check: Nasacort Allergy Reviews
What Are The Symptoms Of A Wine Allergy
Thankfully, a true allergy to alcohol, including wine, is very rare. However, you might have an alcohol intolerance or intolerance or allergy to something included in wine.
Like intolerance to beer, symptoms of a wine intolerance include:
- Nasal congestion
- Facial flushing
Most commonly, people report feeling flushed and get nasal congestion when drinking wine when they have some level of sensitivity or intolerance. Unfortunately, there are a lot of ingredients in wine that can cause some negative reactions.
Alcoholism Is An Allergic Reaction To Alcohol
A lot of East Asians are intolerant to even very modest amounts of alcohol. These people accumulate acetaldehyde, the key metabolite of ethanol, because of a genetic polymorphism of aldehyde dehydrogenase that processes acetaldehyde to nontoxic acetate.
…true alcoholism is an allergic state, the result of gradually increasing sensitization by alcohol over a more or less extended period of time. W.D.Silkworth, 1937.
The view that alcoholism is an allergic reaction to alcohol contends that it is one of two characteristics common to alcoholics. It is also the one held by Alcoholics Anonymous and its millions of members worldwide. For some, thinking of addiction in this manner can help them better understand the disease concept of addiction.AA members believe drink dependency to be a mental and physical disease.
- Mental because it is an obsession of the mind- the sufferer cannot resist a drink despite knowing the negative consequences of having one. Feeling a loss of control and preoccupation with drinking are examples of the mental effects of alcohol. The obsession contributes to the amount of a time an alcoholic would spend thinking about and planning drinking.
- Physical because when drink is taken the sufferers body has an allergic reaction to it and craves more. The sufferer cannot stop drinking.
Similarly, if an alcoholic were to have a drink, they would experience unpleasant consequences. If you have an allergy to peanuts, you probably avoid them as much as possible.
Recommended Reading: What Allergy Medicine Is Stronger Than Zyrtec
Iv Aa Still Supports Theory
However, A.A.s brief recognition was just a slip. A.A. never really changed its doctrine that alcoholism is an allergy. It currently asserts that When the Doctors Opinion was written in the 1930s it was just an opinion. Medical science has progressed since then and has confirmed this opinion as fact.8
Big Book Sponsorship similarly contends that Medical Science has found that there is sound reasoning in the Doctors Opinion. That is, that alcoholism is an allergy.9
An A.A. member wrote that at a meeting the group was studying Dr. Silkworths opinion. When the member informed the group that alcoholism is not a allergy, there was very strong disagrement.10
This isnt surprising. A.A. repeatedly insists that an alcoholic is allergic to alcohol.11 Members assert that Alcoholics are allergic to alcohol.they have an allergic reaction to alcohol, which is unlike anything ever experienced by normal drinkers.12
Allergy Symptoms That Alcohol Makes Worse
Researchers are exploring the complex relationship between alcohol and allergic reactions.
One report, which the American Academy of Allergy Asthma & Immunology cite, found a link between high levels of alcohol use and high IgE levels. IgE is an antibody that suggests that a person may have allergies.
People should note, however, that its authors do not propose that this means that alcohol causes allergies.
Instead, they state that the data indicate that alcohol interacts with a component involving the bodys allergic response.
According to Dr. Phil Lieberman, who speaks on behalf of the AAAI, other studies have shown links between drinking alcoholic beverages and the following allergy symptoms:
Consuming alcoholic beverages has links to increases in allergic reactions. The AAAI report that, in general, alcohol:
- lowers the amount of an allergen necessary to cause a reaction
- makes allergen-related allergic reactions develop more quickly
- increases the severity of allergic reactions
One older study in people with asthma found that over of participants said that drinking alcohol prompted allergy or allergy-like symptoms. Also, 3035 percent said that it made their asthma worse.
Drinking alcohol can also make cases of hives worse.
It is best for people who have gluten intolerance to avoid beer, unless it is gluten-free.
It is also important to remember that ingredients besides alcohol can cause some symptoms.
Read Also: Antibiotics Itchy Skin
Alcohol Allergy Treatment And Prevention
Avoiding alcohol is the only sure way to prevent an alcohol-related reaction.
If you do have a reaction, its effects can range from hives, which may not need medical care, to a more serious, possibly life-threatening reaction . Anaphylaxis caused by an alcohol allergy is treated the same as with any other type of allergy:
- Lie down right away.
Supporting Statements Of This Theory
There is research that shows that people with addictions react to substances differently than other people. People in support of this theory say that physical allergy is the reason why people cannot stop drinking once they begin.
When someone has an allergy to something like lactose, they have an abnormal response to the substance that other people do not have. Because people with addiction have an abnormal response to alcohol that other people do not have: they crave alcohol, alcoholism appears to be similar to an allergy.
Recommended Reading: Does Pseudoephedrine Make You Sleepy
Can Alcohol Make Hives And Skin Conditions Worse
If you are sensitive to alcohol, drinking can cause an allergic reaction and make your hives worse. One study with a patient with a history of hives found that levels of tryptase, a marker of an immune system response, increased with alcohol consumption. The patient developed hives on the chest and upper arms just minutes after drinking alcohol, suggesting that the alcohol caused the hives.
Alcohol consumption could worsen other skin conditions. For example, a review of the research shows that alcohol consumption is linked to psoriasis.
Is Alcohol Intolerance The Same As Being Intoxicated
No, alcohol intolerance is not the same as being intoxicated or drunk. Alcohol intolerance doesnt mean you become drunk faster or after drinking less alcohol. And the condition does not increase your blood alcohol level, either. Often, people with alcohol intolerance drink less, because the symptoms they experience are so unpleasant.
You May Like: Zyrtec Pill
An Aa Explanation Of Cravings
Written by Barefoot Bill L. Barefoot Bill is a revered Alcoholics Anonymous speaker and an alcoholic. Here he writes here about alcohol cravings from the perspective of AA. There is no one right way to recover. AA proposes complete abstinence and working the “12-Steps” as a means to recovering from addiction.
This is an explanation of addiction cravings founded on the teaching and the book of Alcoholics Anonymous written in 1939. Despite some antiquated language, science has proven the concept sound all these years later.
How Alcohol Affects Symptoms
Alcohol itself rarely causes an allergic reaction. More often, it interacts with components in the bodys immune system, causing reactions to lower levels of allergen quicker allergic reactions or more severe allergic reactions. Even the alcohol manufacturing process can trigger reactions in some individuals. Drinking alcohol that has been aged in wooden barrels, for instance, can cause reactions in people with a tree nut sensitivity. Thats something few people with allergies think about when hoisting a glass and settling in for Happy Hour!
Alcohol is found in many common food and household ingredients. If you suffer from allergic reactions to alcohol, your diligence in avoiding it isnt limited to just saying no to vodka. Youll need to scrutinize labels carefully when using any of the following:
- Salad dressings
Read Also: Robitussin Allergy & Cough